Profiting from a Bear Put Spread Strategy in MicroStrategy Stock

Profiting from a Bear Put Spread Strategy in MicroStrategy Stock

MicroStrategy (MSTR) has been experiencing a significant upward movement in recent months, leading some traders to believe it may continue to rise. However, for those with a bearish view, employing a bear put spread options trade in MicroStrategy stock could be an effective strategy.

A bear put spread is a valuable tool in options trading that allows investors to bet against overvalued stocks while having a defined risk and reward, unlike short selling, which carries unlimited risk. Shorting shares based on valuation can be challenging, as a rising stock price would further inflate its overvaluation. MicroStrategy stock, for example, has surged by 20% in the past week and over 235% year-to-date.

Risk management principles suggest that investors should consider reducing their position rather than adding to it when faced with an overvalued stock. Therefore, employing a bear put spread can provide a bearish opportunity on MicroStrategy while effectively limiting risk.

MicroStrategy, led by its founder and CEO Michael Saylor, has transformed the company from a small software name to a leveraged bet on Bitcoin. This strategic move has attracted retail investors seeking exposure to Bitcoin, resulting in MicroStrategy amassing a remarkable $6 billion in assets. However, when assessing the company's value, it becomes apparent that MicroStrategy stock may be significantly overvalued.

MicroStrategy's business simplicity allows for easy valuation, with its software segment estimated to be worth around $200 million. The company holds 152,333 bitcoins, valued at approximately $4.6 billion, which may seem reasonable until considering its $2.2 billion debt. Consequently, an argument can be made that MicroStrategy stock is grossly overvalued and should be priced at around half its current value, approximately $448.

To implement a bear put spread in MicroStrategy stock, investors can purchase a put option and simultaneously sell a put at a lower strike price with the same expiration. For example, buying a 420-strike put while selling a 400-strike put, both expiring on December 15.

At recent trading prices, investors would incur a debit of $970, which represents the maximum loss if MicroStrategy stock trades above 420 upon expiration. The maximum gain is determined by the difference in strike prices minus the debit paid. In this case, the maximum gain would be ($20 - $9.7) x 100 = $1,030 if MSTR trades below 400 at expiration.

This bear put spread strategy can yield profits if the price of MicroStrategy stock moves closer to its fair value without a significant rally in Bitcoin's price. However, it's important to note that markets can remain irrational for longer than expected, potentially resulting in the complete loss of the premium paid if MicroStrategy stock continues to be grossly overvalued.

In conclusion, a bear put spread strategy presents a profitable approach for investors seeking to capitalize on the potential overvaluation of MicroStrategy stock. By limiting risk and defining potential gains, this options trade provides a calculated opportunity for bearish positioning. However, investors should exercise caution and be aware of the possibility of market irrationality and the associated risks involved.

Back to blog